As Bitcoin prices repeatedly fluctuate around $76,000 and are now approaching the $70,000 mark, the longstanding debate between gold advocate Peter Schiff and Bitcoin steadfast supporter Michael Saylor has reignited. Schiff directly criticizes Strategy’s Bitcoin holdings, which amount to approximately $54 billion, claiming they “hardly create any real value,” and mocks that its current price has nearly reached the company’s average cost basis, implying that this high-stakes gamble is on the verge of breaking even or incurring losses.
Schiff states that, based on the current price, Strategy has an unrealized loss of about 3%, and warns that risks could further increase over the next five years. He emphasizes that Bitcoin’s history is still too short to be considered a reliable long-term store of value. In his view, the company’s high concentration of assets in a single cryptocurrency inherently carries systemic risks.
Meanwhile, Saylor’s camp argues that this assessment overlooks the impact of macroeconomic conditions and liquidity cycles. Some community members point out that Strategy’s buying pace spans multiple market phases, and short-term price declines are more likely due to macro tightening and reduced risk appetite rather than a failure of Bitcoin’s fundamentals. The contraction of dollar liquidity and weakness in the US stock market have forced investors to reprice all high-volatility assets.
In terms of market performance, Strategy recently disclosed an unrealized paper loss exceeding $900 million, with MSTR’s stock price falling back to around $133, down more than 6% for the day. Bitcoin also weakened slightly during the same period, further fueling concerns about the company’s financial stability. Nevertheless, Strategy remains the largest corporate holder of Bitcoin globally, with over 710,000 coins, a scale that still holds symbolic significance within the institutional sector.
This “gold versus Bitcoin” value debate is no longer just a clash of individual opinions but a long-term contest between two asset logics. Whether short-term fluctuations will shake Strategy’s confidence remains uncertain, but as the cost basis and market price continue to narrow, risk management and capital structure issues are being pushed into sharper focus.
Disclaimer: The information on this page may come from third parties and does not represent the views or opinions of Gate. The content displayed on this page is for reference only and does not constitute any financial, investment, or legal advice. Gate does not guarantee the accuracy or completeness of the information and shall not be liable for any losses arising from the use of this information. Virtual asset investments carry high risks and are subject to significant price volatility. You may lose all of your invested principal. Please fully understand the relevant risks and make prudent decisions based on your own financial situation and risk tolerance. For details, please refer to
Disclaimer.
Related Articles
Yesterday, U.S. spot Bitcoin ETFs saw net inflows of $240.4 million, with net inflows for two consecutive days.
Gate News message, April 11, according to Farside monitoring, yesterday (April 10) U.S. spot Bitcoin ETFs saw net inflows of $240.4 million, achieving net inflows for two consecutive trading days.
GateNews15m ago
Bitcoin Holds Gains Above $72K As Options Data Reveals Cautious Sentiment
Bitcoin (BTC) is trading near the upper end of its recent range after the latest ceasefire headlines lifted risk appetite across global markets, but the mood beneath the surface is still cautious rather than euphoric. At the time of writing, BTC was around $72,266, after trading between $70,568
BlockChainReporter29m ago
Bitdeer for the week ending April 10 mined 165 BTC and sold all of it, maintaining a zero position
Gate News message, April 11, the Nasdaq-listed Bitcoin mining company Bitdeer released the latest Bitcoin holdings data. As of the week ending April 10, Bitdeer’s Bitcoin mining output was 165 BTC, and it sold 165 BTC in the same period, resulting in a net increase of 0 BTC; it still maintains a zero Bitcoin position.
GateNews32m ago
The Kingdom of Bhutan may have already stopped Bitcoin mining, and hydropower has shifted to selling electricity to India.
After the Kingdom of Bhutan sold 70% of its Bitcoin holdings, it may have stopped or slowed Bitcoin mining, and due to economic pressure it has used more hydropower for exports to India. By contrast, El Salvador has been increasing its Bitcoin holdings.
GateNews1h ago
Bitcoin and Ether ETFs Add Combined $443 Million in Strong Inflow Day
Crypto ETFs staged a strong rebound, with bitcoin and ether both returning to solid inflows. XRP slipped modestly, while Solana activity remained absent.
Key Takeaways:
Bitcoin ETFs saw $358.17 million inflows on April 9, led by Blackrock IBIT, restoring momentum.
Ether ETFs added $85.19 millio
Coinpedia1h ago
A certain CEX saw its market value shrink by more than 50% this year and cut 30% of its workforce. It is reportedly considering converting the founders’ loans into equity.
A major cryptocurrency exchange’s market value has fallen by more than 50%, it has laid off 30% of its staff, and it is considering asking the founders to forgive several hundred million dollars in loans. It lost $585 million last year, plans to exit multiple markets, and senior executives have stepped down. The Winklevoss brothers have not yet said whether they support the proposal.
GateNews2h ago
